World Library  
Flag as Inappropriate
Email this Article

Keith Vaz

Article Id: WHEBN0000354040
Reproduction Date:

Title: Keith Vaz  
Author: World Heritage Encyclopedia
Language: English
Subject: Geoff Hoon, Peter Hain, Teahouse/Questions/Archive 162, Leicester, Administration Committee
Collection: 1956 Births, 21St-Century Roman Catholics, Alumni of Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, British Politicians of South Asian Descent, British Roman Catholics, English People of Indian Descent, Immigrants to England from Aden, Indian Roman Catholics, Labour Party (Uk) Mps, Living People, Members of the Parliament of the United Kingdom for English Constituencies, Members of the Privy Council of the United Kingdom, People Educated at Latymer Upper School, People from East Sheen, People from Twickenham, People of Goan Descent, Political Scandals in the United Kingdom, Uk Mps 1987–92, Uk Mps 1992–97, Uk Mps 1997–2001, Uk Mps 2001–05, Uk Mps 2005–10, Uk Mps 2010–15, Uk Mps 2015–20
Publisher: World Heritage Encyclopedia

Keith Vaz

The Right Honourable
Keith Vaz
Chair of the Home Affairs Committee
Assumed office
26 July 2007
Prime Minister Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Preceded by John Denham
Minister of State for Europe
In office
9 May 1999 – 11 June 2001
Prime Minister Tony Blair
Preceded by Geoff Hoon
Succeeded by Peter Hain
Member of Parliament
for Leicester East
Assumed office
11 June 1987
Preceded by Peter Bruinvels
Majority 14,082 (29.3%)
Personal details
Born (1956-11-26) 26 November 1956
Aden Colony
Political party Labour
Spouse(s) Maria Fernandes
Relations Valerie Vaz (sister)
Children 1 son
1 daughter
Alma mater Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge
Religion Roman Catholicism
Website Official website

Nigel Keith Anthony Standish Vaz (born 26 November 1956) is a British Labour Party politician who has been Member of Parliament (MP) for Leicester East since the 1987 election. He has been the longest-serving Asian MP and has been the Chairman of the Home Affairs Select Committee since July 2007. He was appointed as a member of the Privy Council in June 2006.

Vaz has had Parliamentary and Ministerial responsibilities. He served as the Minister for Europe, Foreign and Commonwealth Office between October 1999 and June 2001 and has been Chairman of the Home Affairs Committee from 2007-


  • Early and personal life 1
  • Employment 2
  • Political life 3
    • Rushdie affair 3.1
    • Leicester IRA attack 3.2
    • Filkin inquiry 3.3
    • Hinduja affair 3.4
    • Suspension from House of Commons 3.5
    • Nadhmi Auchi 3.6
    • Home Affairs Select Committee 3.7
    • Speculation over Counter-Terrorism Bill 3.8
    • Conflict of interest 3.9
    • Detention without charge inquiry 3.10
    • Parliamentary expenses 3.11
    • Patrick Mercer scandal 3.12
    • Alternative medicine 3.13
    • Loudspeaker use during election campaign 3.14
  • Campaign against video game violence 4
  • References 5
  • External links 6

Early and personal life

Vaz was born in 1956 in Aden, to parents from the Indian state of Goa, which accounts for his Goan-Portuguese surname. Vaz is a distant relative of Saint Joseph Vaz, a 17th-century missionary.[1] He moved to England with his family in 1965, settling in Twickenham.[2] His father worked in the airline industry, while his mother held two jobs as a teacher and in Marks & Spencer. Vaz's father committed suicide when his son was 14.[3]

Vaz was educated at Latymer Upper School, Hammersmith followed by Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge. where he studied law. He graduated from Cambridge University with a BA 1st class Honours (1979), MA (1987), and MCFI (1988).

Vaz has two sisters, Valerie (b. 1954), who has been the MP for Walsall South since 2010, and Penny McConnell, who is a solicitor.[4] He lives in London with his wife, Maria Fernandes, and their two children.


Before his political career, Vaz was a practising solicitor. In 1982, he was employed as a solicitor to Richmond upon Thames London Borough Council; and later as a senior solicitor to the London Borough of Islington. This position lasted until 1985, when he moved to Leicester and was employed as a solicitor at the Highfields and Belgrave Law Centre in Leicester. He remained in this role until his election to Parliament in 1987.

Political life

Vaz has been a Labour member since 1982.

In 1983, Vaz stood in the general election as the Labour candidate in the Conservative-Liberal marginal Richmond and Barnes constituency, coming third with a swing away from Labour of 4.3% compared with a national average swing away of 9.3%. He stood as the Labour candidate in the European Parliament election in 1984 for Surrey West, coming third.

On 11 June 1987, Vaz was elected as the Member of Parliament for Leicester East with a majority of 1,924. He was re-elected in 1992 (majority of 11,316), 1997 (majority of 18,422), 2001 (majority of 13,442), 2005 (majority of 15,867), 2010 (majority of 14,082) and 2015 (majority of 18,352).

Vaz has held a variety of parliamentary posts. Between 1987 and 1992, he was a member of the Home Affairs Select Committee, of which he has been the Chair since July 2007. Between 1993 and 1994, he was a member of the Executive Committee Inter-Parliamentary Union. Finally, between December 2002 and July 2007, Vaz acted as a senior Labour Member of the Select Committee for Constitutional Affairs.

In 1992, Vaz was given the role of Shadow Junior Environment Minister with responsibility for planning and regeneration, his first frontbench role. He remained in this position until 1997, when he was given his first Government post as the Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Attorney General and Solicitor General. Vaz then served as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Lord Chancellor's Department between May and October 1999.[5] This was quickly followed by his appointment as the Minister for Europe, Foreign and Commonwealth Office. He served in this position from October 1999 and June 2001.[5]

Other positions currently held include as an elected member of the National Executive Committee and as the Vice-Chair of Women, Race and Equality Committee of the Labour Party. He has held both of these positions since March 2007. Since 2000, he has been a patron of the Labour Party Race Action Group and in 2006 he was appointed the Chairman of the Ethnic Minority Taskforce.

Rushdie affair

Shortly after being elected in 1989, Vaz led a march of several thousands of Muslims in Leicester calling for Salman Rushdie's book The Satanic Verses to be banned.[6] According to Rushdie's autobiography Joseph Anton, as quoted by Douglas Murray in The Spectator, Vaz had earlier promised his support against the fatwa:

Vaz said, in that phone conversation, that what had happened was ‘appalling, absolutely appalling,’ and promised his ‘full support’. A few weeks later he was one of the main speakers at a demonstration against The Satanic Verses attended by over three thousand Muslims, and described that event as ‘one of the great days in the history of Islam and Great Britain.’[7]

Leicester IRA attack

In February 1990, after a bombing attack by the Provisional Irish Republican Army against a British Army recruiting centre in Leicester, Vaz publicly suggested that the Army had stored explosives on the premises.[8]

Filkin inquiry

In February 2000, the Parliamentary standards watchdog Elizabeth Filkin began an investigation after allegations that Vaz had accepted several thousand pounds from a solicitor, Sarosh Zaiwalla, which he had failed to declare. The allegations were made by Andrew Milne, a former partner of Zaiwalla and were denied by both Vaz and Zaiwalla.[9][10] He was censured for a single allegation – that he had failed to register two payments worth £4,500 in total from solicitor Sarosh Zaiwalla.[11] Elizabeth Filkin accused Vaz of blocking her investigation into eighteen of the allegations.[12]

Hinduja affair

In January 2001, immigration minister Barbara Roche revealed in a written Commons reply that Vaz, along with Peter Mandelson and other MPs, had contacted the Home Office about the Hinduja brothers. She said that Vaz had made inquiries about when a decision on their application for citizenship could be expected.[13]

On 25 January, Vaz had become the focus of Opposition questions about the Hinduja affair and many parliamentary questions were tabled, demanding that he fully disclose his role. Vaz said via a Foreign Office spokesman that he would be "fully prepared" to answer questions put to him by Sir Anthony Hammond QC who had been asked by the Prime Minister to carry out an inquiry into the affair.

Vaz had known the Hinduja brothers for some time; he had been present when the charitable Hinduja Foundation was set up in 1993, and also delivered a speech in 1998 when the brothers invited Tony and Cherie Blair to a Diwali celebration.[14]

On 26 January 2001, John Redwood MP accused Prime Minister Tony Blair of prejudicing the independent inquiry into the Hinduja passport affair, after Blair declared that the Foreign Office minister Keith Vaz had not done "anything wrong".[15] On the same day, Vaz told reporters that they would "regret" their behaviour once the facts of the case were revealed. "Some of you are going to look very foolish when this report comes out. Some of the stuff you said about Peter, and about others and me, you'll regret very much when the facts come out," he said. When asked why the passport application of one of the Hinduja brothers had been processed more quickly than normal, being processed and sanctioned in six months when the process can take up to two years, he replied, "It is not unusual."[16]

On 29 January, the government confirmed that the Hinduja Foundation had held a reception for Vaz in September 1999 to celebrate his appointment as the first Asian Minister in recent times. The party was not listed by Vaz in House of Commons register of Members' Interests and John Redwood, then head of the Conservative Parliamentary Campaigns Unit, questioned Vaz's judgement in accepting the hospitality.[17]

In March, Vaz was ordered to co-operate fully with a new inquiry launched into his financial affairs by Elizabeth Filkin.

Parliament of the United Kingdom
Preceded by
Peter Bruinvels
Member of Parliament
for Leicester East

Political offices
Preceded by
Geoff Hoon
Minister for Europe
Succeeded by
Peter Hain

External links

  1. ^ "Relative of British MP to become Sri Lanka’s first saint".  
  2. ^ "Keith Vaz: The 'Teflon MP' who enjoys the limelight". Retrieved 19 September 2014. 
  3. ^ Laville, Sandra (2 January 2013). "'"Keith Vaz on Jacintha Saldanha's children: This could be me 42 years ago.  
  4. ^ Maurice Weaver "Minister's sister wins race bias settlement", Daily Telegraph, 23 March 2001
  5. ^ a b c d e "Keith Vaz, Labour MP for Leicester East". Retrieved 6 June 2010. 
  6. ^ No Such Thing as Society by Andy McSmith, Constable 2011, page 106 ISBN 978-1-84901-979-8
  7. ^ "Keith Vaz and Salman Rushdie". The Spectator. 
  8. ^ "Keith Vaz: Minister and networker". BBC News. 26 January 2001. 
  9. ^ Morris, Nigel (7 March 2001). "Vaz did not break code of conduct, says Filkin report".  
  10. ^ Hosken, Andrew. "Keith Vaz's property holdings".  
  11. ^ "'"Vaz 'misled inquiry. BBC News. 5 June 2001. 
  12. ^ "Tories keep heat on Vaz". BBC News. 19 March 2001. 
  13. ^ Grice, Andrew (22 January 2001). "MPs to quiz Mandelson on passport for Hinduja".  
  14. ^ Sengupta, Kim (26 January 2001). "Vaz sidesteps questions on links with Hindujas".  
  15. ^ Waugh, Paul; Sengupta, Kim (27 January 2001). "Vaz defiant over his role in Hinduja passport scandal".  
  16. ^ Waugh, Paul; Sengupta, Kim (27 January 2001). "Vaz defiant over his role in Hinduja passport scandal".  
  17. ^ Woolf, Marie (30 January 2001). "Hindujas held party to celebrate Vaz being appointed a minister".  
  18. ^ Woolf, Marie (22 March 2001). "Filkin launches new investigation into cash links between Vaz and Hindujas".  
  19. ^ Grice, Andrew; Castle, Stephen (24 March 2001). "Downing Street orders Vaz to help inquiry".  
  20. ^ George, Jones; Womack, Sarah (19 June 2001). "Vaz admits greater role over Hinduja passport".  
  21. ^ Woolf, Marie; Morris, Andrew (12 June 2001). "After months of claims and counter claims, Vaz is finally sacked as Minister for Europe".  
  22. ^ Wintour, Patrick (24 December 2001). "Vaz cleared over Hinduja payments to wife".  
  23. ^ a b c Hall, Sarah (9 February 2002). "Vaz brought about the very disaster he tried to avoid".  
  24. ^ Hall, Sarah (9 February 2002). "'It's incredible that he should try to smear me'".  
  25. ^ "Vaz faces Commons suspension". BBC News. 8 February 2002. 
  26. ^ "Standards and Privileges Committee report".  
  27. ^ Watson, Roland (17 March 2001). "Lawyer claims human rights were breached".  
  28. ^ a b c d Barnett, Antony; Bright, Martin (27 May 2001). "Vaz helped tycoon in fraud scandal".  
  29. ^ Syal, Rajeev (28 September 2008). "Vaz under pressure over 28-day query".  
  30. ^ Carr, Simon (27 July 2007). "House sees through how Harriet works".  
  31. ^ "Winning candidates for select committee Chairs announced". UK Parliament. 18 June 2015. Retrieved 19 June 2015. 
  32. ^ a b c Robert, Winnett (2 July 2008). "Gordon Brown under pressure over 'reward' for Keith Vaz over terror bill".  
  33. ^ "The Rt Hon Keith Vaz MP Publication: The Daily Telegraph Clauses Noted: 1, 10". The Press Council. 18 Dec 2008. Retrieved 6 June 2010. 
  34. ^ Helm, Toby; Syal, Rajeev (14 September 2008). "Labour MP under pressure over letter".  
  35. ^ Helm, Toby; Syal, Rajeev (28 September 2008). "Vaz under pressure over 28-day query".  
  36. ^ a b Jon Swaine, Keith Vaz: £75,000 for a flat 12 miles from home Daily Telegraph (9 May 2009)
  37. ^ "Full list of MPs' expenses repayments order of amount repayable". BBC news. 4 February 2010. Retrieved 1 April 2010. 
  38. ^ "Review of past ACA payments" (PDF). House of Commons Members Estimate Committee. 4 February 2010. Retrieved 5 February 2010. 
  39. ^ "MPs' expenses: Old rules v new rules". BBC News. 29 March 2010. Retrieved 25 April 2010. 
  40. ^ a b "Committee on Standards report on Patrick Mercer" (PDF). House of Commons. 1 May 2014. Retrieved 1 May 2014. 
  41. ^ Tredinnick, David (29 June 2010). "Early Day Motion No. 342 British Medical Association Motions on Homeopathy". 
  42. ^ Tredinnick, David (29 June 2010). "Early Day Motion No. 284 British Medical Association Motions on Homeopathy". 
  43. ^ "'Noise row' erupts over Keith Vaz's loud-hailer", ITV News, 28 April 2015
  44. ^ "PM backs violent game inquiry". BBC. 15 September 2004. Retrieved 6 June 2010. 
  45. ^ "Censors ban 'brutal' video game". BBC. 19 June 2004. Retrieved 6 June 2010. 
  46. ^ a b "MP attacks school bullying game". BBC News. 26 October 2005. 
  47. ^ "EDM 907 Video games and shootings". UK Parliament. 27 October 2010. Retrieved 22 November 2010. 


In October 2010, Vaz put down an Early Day Motion noting that the 2009–10 Malmö shootings "have been associated with the violent video game Counter-Strike." The EDM also noted that the game had been previously banned in Brazil and also been associated with US College Campus massacres in 2007. It called on the Government to ensure the purchase of video games by minors was controlled and that parents were provided with clear information on any violent content.[47]

Vaz has also criticised Bully, which had a pre-release screenshot showing three uniformed pupils fighting and kicking.[46] In 2005, he asked Geoff Hoon: "Does the leader of the house share my concern at the decision of Rockstar Games to publish a new game called Bully in which players use their on-screen persona to kick and punch other schoolchildren?"[46] Due to the controversy surrounding the Bully title, the game was released in the UK in 2006 under an alternate name though the original title was restored when the game was re-released in 2008 with a BBFC 15 rating and some positive reviews.

Following the February 2004 murder of a fourteen-year-old boy, Vaz asked for an investigation between the video games and violence, saying the parents of the victim believe that the killer was influenced by the video game Manhunt. Although the police dismissed the claim and the only copy found belonged to the victim, Tony Blair said the game was unsuitable for children and agreed to discuss with the Home Secretary what action could be taken.[44] The sequel, Manhunt 2, described by the British Board of Film Censors as "distinguishable its unremitting bleakness and callousness of tone", became the first video game banned by the BBFC in the UK for 10 years. Vaz said: "This is an excellent decision by the British Board of Film Classification, showing that game publishers cannot expect to get interactive games where players take the part of killers engaged in 'casual sadism' and murder."[45]

Campaign against video game violence

According to ITV News, the incident is under investigation by the Leicester City Council.[43]

A video showing Vaz speaking using loudspeakers from a campaign car caused a row with the Leicester Conservatives. Using a loudspeaker for political campaigning is an offence that carries a penalty of up to £5000.

Loudspeaker use during election campaign

Vaz has signed several early day motions sponsored by David Tredinnick supporting the continued funding of homoeopathy on the National Health Service.[41][42]

Alternative medicine

Vaz was one of the MPs who agreed to be on the all-party parliamentary group on Fiji proposed by Patrick Mercer MP as part of his paid advocacy for fake lobbyists. Mercer was recorded describing Vaz as "a crook of the first order", adding that he had "never met an operator like him... I mean it's not always completely ethical but it's stunning, he is an operator". Mercer's comments on Vaz and the other Parliamentarians were a reason for the Committee on Standards deciding that he had brought the House of Commons into disrepute.[40][40]

Patrick Mercer scandal

Vaz's total expenses of £173,937 in 2008/2009 were ranked 45th out of 647 MPs, with office running costs and staffing costs accounting for 70% of this.[5] The register of Member's interests shows that he owns the constituency office.[5]
His second home expenses, ranked 83 out of 647 at £23,831 in 2008/2009[5] were the subject of a Daily Telegraph article.[36] Vaz who lives in Stanmore, a 45-minute journey time from Parliament, claimed mortgage interest on a flat in Westminster he bought in 2003.
In May 2007, after claiming for the flat's service and council tax, he switched his designated second home to his constituency office and bought furniture.[36] The report into the Parliamentary expenses scandal by Sir Thomas Legg showed that 343 MPs had been asked to repay some money[37] and Vaz was asked to repay £1514 due to furnishing items exceeding allowable cost.[38] New expenses rules published by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority which came into force after the 2010 general election limit the second home allowance to £1,450 a month, i.e. the Westminster cost of renting a one bedroomed flat. Profits made on existing second homes will be recouped.[39]

Parliamentary expenses

Vaz denied that he invited Brown to contribute, except as a witness to the committee.[35]

Shami Chakrabarti, director of human rights group Liberty, compared it to a judge deciding a case privately emailing one of the parties to seek their suggestions.

In September 2008, Vaz came under pressure when it was revealed that he had sought the private views of Prime Minister Gordon Brown in connection with the Committee's independent report into government plans to extend the detention of terror suspects beyond 28 days. The Guardian reported that emails suggested that Vaz had secretly contacted the Prime Minister about the committee's draft report and proposed a meeting because "we need to get his [Brown's] suggestions". An email was sent in November 2007 to Ian Austin, Gordon Brown's parliamentary private secretary, and copied to Fiona Gordon, at the time Brown's political adviser. Another leaked email showed that Vaz had also sent extracts of the committee's draft report to the former Lord Chancellor, Lord Falconer, for his comments; according to Parliament's standing orders, the chairman of the Select Committee cannot take evidence from a witness without at least two other committee members being present.

In July 2007, Vaz was appointed chairman of the Home Affairs Select Committee. Select committee members are usually proposed by the Committee of Selection, but Vaz was the only nomination made by Commons Leader Harriet Harman.

Detention without charge inquiry

Liberal Democrat deputy leader Vince Cable said that Vaz should make a public statement to clear up his role in the affair. "It is quite unreasonable that an independent regulator should have been undermined in this way. I would hope that the chairman of the home affairs select committee will give a full public statement."[34]

The Solicitors Regulation Authority began an investigation into Mireskandari's legal firm, Dean and Dean, in January 2008 after a number of complaints about its conduct. Vaz wrote a joint letter with fellow Labour MP Virendra Sharma to the authority's chief executive, Anthony Townsend, in February 2008 on official House of Commons stationery. He cited a complaint he had received from Mireskandari and alleged "discriminatory conduct" in its investigation into Dean and Dean. The Authority was forced to set up an independent working party to look into whether it had disproportionately targeted non-white lawyers for investigation.

In September 2008, Vaz faced pressure to explain why he failed to declare an interest when he intervened in an official investigation into the business dealings of a close friend, solicitor Shahrokh Mireskandari, who has played a role in several racial discrimination cases against the Metropolitan Police, and who was representing Assistant Commissioner Tarique Ghaffur in his racial discrimination case against Scotland Yard Commissioner Sir Ian Blair.

Conflict of interest

Vaz wrote to the Press Council complaining the story was inaccurate, that the letter had been obtained by subterfuge and that he had not been contacted before the story was published. The complaint was rejected as the article made it clear that the reports of an honour were just speculation which Vaz had already publicly denied.[33]

“Dear Keith... Just a quick note to thank you for all your help during the period leading up to last Wednesday’s vote. I wanted you to know how much I appreciated all your help. I trust that it will be appropriately rewarded!... With thanks and best wishes, Geoff.”[32]

Vaz's backing for the 42-day terrorist detention without charge "was seen as crucial by the Government."[32] During the debate on 10 June 2008, the day before the key vote, Vaz was asked in Parliament whether he had been offered an honour for his support. He said: “No, it was certainly not offered—but I do not know; there is still time.”[32] The Daily Telegraph printed a hand written letter to Vaz, written the day after the vote, Geoff Hoon wrote:

Speculation over Counter-Terrorism Bill

Vaz was elected Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee, replacing John Denham, on 26 July 2007. He was unusually nominated to the Committee by government minister Harriet Harman, Leader of the House of Commons and Lord Privy Seal, rather than by the quasi-independent Committee of Selection which, under the Standing Orders of the House, nominates members to select committees.[29] Harman argued that this was because there was not sufficient time to go through the usual procedure before the impending summer recess. The Chairman of the Committee of Selection told the House that the Committee had been ready to meet earlier that week, but had been advised by the Government that there was no business for it to transact.[30] Vaz was re-elected to the Committee's chairmanship in June 2015.[31]

Home Affairs Select Committee

Since 2003, he has been a Member of the Constitutional Affairs Select Committee.

Labour confirmed in May 2001 that Auchi had called Vaz at home about the arrest warrant to ask him for advice. A spokesman said that Vaz "made some factual inquiries to the Home Office about the [extradition] procedure." This included advising Auchi to consult his local MP. The spokesman stressed that Vaz acted properly at all times and was often contacted by members of Britain's ethnic communities for help. In a Commons answer to Liberal Democrat MP Norman Baker earlier the same month Vaz confirmed that "details of enquiries by Mr Auchi have been passed to the Home Office".[28]

Vaz was a director of the British arm of Auchi's corporation, General Mediterranean Holdings, whose previous directors had included Lords Steel and Lamont, and Jacques Santer. Vaz used his political influence on GMH's behalf; this included a party in the Park Lane Hilton to celebrate the 20th anniversary of GMH on 23 April 1999, where Lord Sainsbury presented Auchi with a painting of the House of Commons signed by Tony Blair, the Opposition leaders, and over 100 other leading British politicians. Lord Sainsbury later told The Observer that he did this "as a favour for Keith Vaz". In May 1999, Vaz resigned his post as a director after he was appointed a Minister. In a statement to The Observer, a GMH spokesman said that Vaz had been invited to become a GMH director in January 1999, yet company accounts showed Vaz as a director for the financial year ending December 1998.[28]

Auchi was wanted for questioning by French police for his alleged role in the notorious Elf Aquitaine fraud scandal which led to the arrest of a former French Foreign Minister. The warrant issued by French authorities in July 2000 Auchi of "complicity in the misuse of company assets and receiving embezzled company assets". It also covered Auchi's associate Nasir Abid and stated that, if found guilty of the alleged offences, both men could face 109 years in jail.[28]

In 2001, it was revealed that Vaz had assisted Anglo-Iraqi billionaire Nadhmi Auchi in his attempts to avoid extradition to France. Opposition MPs called for an investigation into what one dubbed "Hinduja Mark II".[28]

Nadhmi Auchi

Vaz was represented by his solicitor Sir Geoffrey Bindman.[27]

It was concluded that Vaz had "committed serious breaches of the Code of Conduct and showed contempt for the House" and it was recommended that he be suspended from the House of Commons for one month.[26]

  • That he had given misleading information to the Standards and Privileges Committee and Elizabeth Filkin about his financial relationship to the Hinduja brothers.
  • That he had failed to register his paid employment at the Leicester Law Centre when he first entered Parliament in 1987.
  • That he had failed to register a donation from the Caparo group in 1993.

The complaints the committee upheld against Mr Vaz were:[25]

A letter to Elizabeth Filkin from Detective Superintendent Nick Gargan made it plain that the police did not believe Vaz's mother ever received the phone call and the person who came closest to being prosecuted was not Eggington but Vaz. Gargan said that the police had considered a range of possible offences, including wasteful employment of the police, and an attempt to pervert the course of justice. Leicestershire police eventually decided not to prosecute. "We cannot rule out a tactical motivation for Mr Vaz's contact with Leicestershire Constabulary but the evidence does not support further investigation of any attempt to pervert the course of justice."[23]

In late 2001, Vaz complained to Leicestershire police that his mother had been upset by a telephone call from "a woman named Mrs Egginton", who claimed to be a police officer. The accusations led to Ms. Eggington being questioned by police.[24] Vaz also wrote a letter of complaint to Elizabeth Filkin, but when she tried to make inquiries Vaz accused her of interfering with a police inquiry and threatened to report her to the Speaker of the House of Commons. Eggington denied that she had ever telephoned Vaz's mother and offered her home and mobile telephone records as evidence. The Commons committee decided that she was telling the truth. They added: "Mr Vaz recklessly made a damaging allegation against Miss Eggington, which was not true and which could have intimidated Miss Eggington and undermined her credibility."

Eileen Eggington, a retired police officer who had served 34 years in the Metropolitan Police, including a period as deputy head of Special Branch, wanted to help a friend, Mary Grestny, who had worked as personal assistant to Vaz's wife. After leaving the job in May 2000, Grestny dictated a seven-page statement about Mrs Vaz to Eggington in March 2001, who sent it to Elizabeth Filkin. Grestny's statement included allegations that Mr and Mrs Vaz had employed an illegal immigrant as their nanny and that they had been receiving gifts from Asian businessmen such as the Hinduja brothers. The allegations were denied by Mr Vaz and the Committee found no evidence to support them.[23]

In 2002, Vaz was suspended from the House of Commons for one month after a Committee on Standards and Privileges inquiry found that he had made false allegations against Eileen Eggington, a former policewoman. The committee concluded that "Mr Vaz recklessly made a damaging allegation against Miss Eggington to the Commissioner, which was not true, and which could have intimidated Miss Eggington or undermined her credibility".[23]

Suspension from House of Commons

In December 2001, Elizabeth Filkin cleared Vaz of failing to register payments to his wife's law firm by the Hinduja brothers, but said that he had colluded with his wife to conceal the payments. Filkin's report said that the payments had been given to his wife for legal advice on immigration issues and concluded that Vaz had gained no direct personal benefit, and that Commons rules did not require him to disclose payments made to his wife. She did, however, criticise him for his secrecy, saying, "It is clear to me there has been deliberate collusion over many months between Mr Vaz and his wife to conceal this fact and to prevent me from obtaining accurate information about his possible financial relationship with the Hinduja family".[22]

On 11 June 2001, Vaz was dismissed from his post as Europe Minister, to be replaced by Peter Hain. The Prime Minister's office said that Vaz had written to Tony Blair stating his wish to stand down for health reasons.[21]

In June 2001, Vaz said that he had made representations during the Hinduja brothers' applications for British citizenship while a backbench MP. Tony Blair also admitted that Vaz had "made representations" on behalf of other Asians.[20]


This article was sourced from Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. World Heritage Encyclopedia content is assembled from numerous content providers, Open Access Publishing, and in compliance with The Fair Access to Science and Technology Research Act (FASTR), Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., Public Library of Science, The Encyclopedia of Life, Open Book Publishers (OBP), PubMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Center for Biotechnology Information, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (NIH), U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, and, which sources content from all federal, state, local, tribal, and territorial government publication portals (.gov, .mil, .edu). Funding for and content contributors is made possible from the U.S. Congress, E-Government Act of 2002.
Crowd sourced content that is contributed to World Heritage Encyclopedia is peer reviewed and edited by our editorial staff to ensure quality scholarly research articles.
By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. World Heritage Encyclopedia™ is a registered trademark of the World Public Library Association, a non-profit organization.

Copyright © World Library Foundation. All rights reserved. eBooks from Project Gutenberg are sponsored by the World Library Foundation,
a 501c(4) Member's Support Non-Profit Organization, and is NOT affiliated with any governmental agency or department.